Bitcoin for payments a distant dream
Bitcoin for payments a distant dream
The use of Bitcoin for commercial payments has dropped dramatically this year, even as the original digital coin starts to fulfil one of the basic features of any payment currency: stability.
The value of Bitcoins handled by major payment processors shrivelled nearly 80% in the year to September, data from blockchain researcher Chainalysis shows. That suggests the crypto-currency is struggling to mature from a speculative asset to a serious alternative to state-issued money.
Months of relative calm in Bitcoin prices after the previous wild swings fuelled hopes it would become widely used for payments, its intended purpose.
But its collapse in use as a payment currency has instead left big finance and crypto insiders eyeing better technological infrastructure to help Bitcoin take off as a way to pay.
"There would have to be a stability requirement if it is to become another form of money," said Joni Teves, a strategist at UBS in London.
"But one thing that would take Bitcoin into the mainstream is scalability: is it able to process the value or volume of transactions that money tends to do?"
The blockchain technology, where all Bitcoin activity is recorded and validated, can only process a fraction of the transactions per second that major credit card companies can. That renders its mass use impractical.
Bitcoin still endures torrid swings in price, as this week's 30% plunge shows. For a while last month, though, the crypto-currency was more stable than US stocks.
Despite that growing stability, the value of Bitcoin payments collapsed to $96 million in September from a December high of $427 million, the data from Chainalysis shows.
The firm surveyed 17 Bitcoin payments processors, including BitPay, one of the biggest. Most merchants that accept Bitcoin do not do so directly, instead using intermediaries like BitPay to covert Bitcoin to fiat currencies.
Comprehensive data on Bitcoin used for payments is patchy, as trades with other currencies tend to be included along with its use for commercial payments.
That said, separate figures for individual payments processors reflect the downward trend. At Coinpayments, for example, incoming and outgoing transactions slumped by more than half between January and October, according to blockchain analysis site OXT.
Coinpayments did not respond to requests for comment.
"Bitcoin payments processing is seeing a slow but consistent decline," said Lex Sokolin, global director of fintech strategy at research firm Autonomous Next, of the data on Coinpayments.
Ten years later
Through its first decade, Bitcoin has attracted a mix of investors, some convinced it can reshape global finance by displacing traditional means of payments and others attracted by rapid gains that pushed it close to $20 000 in December.
It has since lost three-quarters of its value, falling below $4 500 on Tuesday, burning businesses along the way that had hoped to profit from growing investor interest.
Chip designer Nvidia, for example, saw its shares fall sharply last week after it blamed disappointing results on unsold chips piling up after the crypto-currency mining boom evaporated.
Bitcoin's relative stability this year has nevertheless raised expectations that its payments use by both individuals and companies will spread.
"The lack of volatility is a good step in the right direction that starts to make it viable for some of the non-retail use cases," said Zeeshan Feroz, UK CEO of Coinbase, one of the biggest crypto-currency exchanges.
But both mainstream financial firms and crypto-currency entrepreneurs say stability is not enough.
To gain traction, Bitcoin needs to be faster and cheaper, they say. Clearer rules on an asset that has vexed financial regulators across the world would also help to give users a sense of legitimacy, UBS's Teves said.
While coordinated regulation remains far off, some developments designed to address the so-called "scalability" problem (how many transactions per second the Bitcoin network can handle) are under way.
Though in its infancy, the lightning network (code that can be added to the Bitcoin blockchain designed to make payments faster and cheaper) is growing in use and capacity.
The network this week reached a record 4 101 "nodes" or computers that run its software, according to data aggregator 1ML, a rise of more than a quarter since August.
Lightning is popular, users say, because it allows users to send money to one another instead of having to complete time-consuming transactions on the blockchain.
"Lightning solves some of Bitcoin's scaling issue," said Ed Cooper, who oversees crypto-currencies at fintech start-up Revolut. "It's getting payments into the wild, into the Bitcoin network."